A Conflicting Evidence Case In Parts: Death Records

I’ve talked about my grandmother, Jennie Elizabeth Payne in past posts: How Eight Children Ended Up Living Alone in 1930 and The Questions a Record Begs Us to Ask

I’ve always had trouble with the conflicting evidence around the birth of her youngest brother Otto.

Otto Baxter Payne is believed to be the youngest child of James Robert Payne and Eva Georgia Baxter.  Otto’s gravestone states that he was born December 16, 19231.  James’ death certificate states that he died on January 23, 19232. If these two dates are correct, it is highly unlikely that James is Otto’s father. If Otto was born in 1922 it would be possible for James to be his father.

Now I obviously could order the birth certificate, and assuming it was correct know the answer. But basic methodology says you need two sources from separate informants. AND I could use some practice in conflicting evidence. So I’ll begin my search using just online evidence.

Today, I’m going to look at the death records I have found.

Death Records for Otto Baxter Payne

1. Find A Grave, database and images (http://findagrave.com : accessed 17 Oct 2013), memorial page for Otto B Payne,  Find A Grave Memorial no. 11082230, citing Mountain Rest Cemetery, Kings Mountain, Cleveland County, North Carolina.

Comment: The tombstone states that Otto died on November 3, 1993 at the age of 75.  He was born on December 16, 1923. The source of the information is unknown.

Genealogically significant facts:

  • Name: Otto B Payne
  • Birth: Dec 16, 1923
  • Death: Nov 3, 1999
  • Served as a TEC 4 in the US Army  and a SSGT in the US Air Force in World War II and Korea
  • Has a Christian Cross on the tombstone
  • Buried in Mountain Rest Cemetery, Kings Mountain, NC

2. U.S. Veterans Gravesites, ca.1775-2006, database, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 17 Oct 2013), entry for Otto B Payne, died 3 Nov 1999; citing National Cemetery Administration, Nationwide Gravesite Locator.veterans-gravesite-otto-baxter-payne

Comment: This is an index to veteran’s tombstones and the informant is unknown.  It is possible that the information in this index is taken from Otto’s Tombstone.

Genealogically significant facts:

  • Name: Otto B Payne
  • Birth: Dec 16, 1923
  • Death: Nov 3, 1999
  • Service Info: Tec 4 US Army World War II, Korea
  • Cemetery: Mountain Rest Cemetery
  • Cemetery Address: S Dilling St Kings Mountain, NC, 28086

3. Social Security Administration, “Social Security Death Index,” database, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed 17 Oct 2013), entry for Otto B Payne, 1923, SS no. [REDACTED FOR PRIVATE USE].ssdi-otto-baxter-payne-2

Comment: It is very likely that Otto supplied the information on his SSN application.  He would have applied before 1951 and at that time he thought his birthday was December 15, 1922.

Genealogically significant facts:

  • Name: Otto B Payne
  • SSN: XXX-XX-XXXX
  • Last Residence: 28111 Monroe, Union, North Carolina, USA
  • Born: 15 Dec 1922
  • Died: 3 Nov 1999
  • State SSN issued: North Carolina (Before 1951)

4.  “MONROE – Otto B Payne,” Charlotte (North Carolina) Observer, 4 Nov 1999; online transcription, “Newspaper Archives, 1690-2010,” GenealogyBank.com (http://www.genealogybank.com : accessed 22 Oct 2013).

Comment: We do not know who the informant is for this obituary or if they knew Otto’s age or if they were guessing.  If his age is correct, then he was born in 1923 and not 1922.

Genealogically significant facts:

  • Name: Otto B Payne
  • Parents: James Robert Payne, Georgia Ann Baxter payne
  • Died: Nov 3, 1999
  • Died at age 75 [ if his birth day was Dec 15 or 16, then he was born in 1923]
  • Church: Grace United Methodist Church
  • Military: Veteran WWII, U.S. Army
  • Interred: Mountain Rest Cemetery, Kings Mountain, NC, Nov 5, 1999
  • Surviving family: Cindy Payne, Monroe, NC, daughter; Eva Payne Avery, Duback, LA, sister; numerous nieces and nephews.

Analysis of the Records

From the death records, we already have conflicting evidence.  3 records (one is an index) state that he was born in 1923 and 1 states that he was born in 1922.  None of these are definitive in proving what year he was born.  Although I do think they demonstrate the conflict pretty well.

Tomorrow, we will analyze the birth records that are available online.

Footnotes

1. Find A Grave, database and images (http://findagrave.com : accessed 17 Oct 2013), memorial page for Otto B Payne,  Find A Grave Memorial no. 11082230, citing Mountain Rest Cemetery, Kings Mountain, Cleveland County, North Carolina.
2. “North Carolina Death Certificates, 1909-1975,” database online, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : accessed  8 Nov 2009), entry for James R Payne, death date 5 Jan 1923; citing North Carolina State Board of Health, Bureau of Vital Statistics, North Carolina Death Certificates; North Carolina State Archives, Raleigh, North Carolina.

One thought on “A Conflicting Evidence Case In Parts: Death Records”

  1. I knew Otto Payne. His brother, Floyd, was my Godfather.
    -Jim Payseur
    contact me at I have some questions, too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s